The research on the reliability of methods for hot-rolled steel bars with middle and small diameter

by Jizhen Xia,Heng Sun*,Xiaowei Fong* and Fei Huang*

NDT Teachig Research Lab. of NANCHANG Institute of aeronautical Technology

note: The article is first published on "6th APNDT(Asia-Pacific region Conference on Non-Destructive Testing)" (Blenheim,NEW ZEALAND,5-9 March,1990),and <NDE & E international>Vol.24,No.6,1991 P313-315
* The  Heng Sun,Xiaowei Fong and Fei Huang were students of NDT speciality in NANCHANG Institute of Aeronautical Technology,graduated in 1988.
Abstract
This article researched on the reliability of UT methods for hot-rolled steel bars with 40~60mm dia. by the experiment and com[parison analysis on the testing methods of direct contact with the bars along the circumferential surface using the straight beam probe("S"probe),twin crystal probe which the probe face's comtouring is suit to the bar curvature("SR"probe) and straight beam probe with delay block("SD"probe).It obtained the distribution state diagrams of the echo-sound pressure and the effective testing range in the cross-section of bars.The conclusion is that the methods using the "SR"probe and the "SD"probe may assure the UT's quality better for the steel bars with the diameter equal or smaller than 60mm,but the "S"probe is not applicable.
Key word: UT,Sound-field,Probe,Reliability
Introduction
There are different methods for hot-rolled steel bars with 40~60mm dia. in UT.For these bars,the article is testing by means of direct contact with the circumferential surface of bars using the straight beam probe("S"probe),twin crystal probe which the probe face's comtouring is suit to the bar curvature by make the initial plane of probe face to curvature("SR"probe) and straight beam probe with plastic delay block("SD"probe).According to the relation between amplitude of echo from artifical reflector(traversed hole) in the bar and its places,we drawn out the distribution state diagrams of echo-sound pressure in the cross-section of the bar,and defined the effective testing range.The reliability of these methods is compared and analysed to seek the best testing method which is suit to inspecting in field.
Test samples
The samples were cutted from supplyed "No.45 steel"(a kind of middle-carbon steel)bars with 40,50 and 60mm normal dia. separately.There are 5 samples for each dia. and they have the length of 60mm all.The two ends of every sample lathed to plane,then drill hole perpendicular to the endface.The size of hole is Φ1x20mm.so there are 10 places for the hole in the bar of each dia. The arrangement of hole's place is in accordance with approximate equal ratio array(table 1).
Table 1: The arrangement of hole's place
sample No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

distance from the centre of the bar

sample dia.                    
40mm 0 3 6 8.5 11 13 14.5 16 17 18
50mm 0 4.5 8.5 12 15 17.5 19.5 21 22 23
60mm 0 5.5 10.5 14.5 18 21 23.5 25.5 27 28
Testing method
The testing is applied using 3 methods as shown in fig.1.

fig.1 (a)-"S"probe;(b)-"SR"probe;(c)"SD"probe
The internal line is 32 equal space,and the out short line is 64 equal space.

At first,we'll find up the maximal echo-amplitude from the traversed hole on the sample's centre,then adjust it to 50% height on the screen of ultrasonic flaw detector(u.f.d) as basic level(0dB).


Afterward,we'll measure the echo-amplitude from other 9 holes.The sample's cross-section is divided into 32 equal spaces for measuring and the neighbourhood of circumferential face is into 64 equal spaces due to the space larger(fig.1).The measuring is operated along the lines of clockwise by means of turning the sample.According to difference(dB) between the basic level and echo-amplitude from these holes at different place,we can draw out the distribution state diagrams of echo-sound pressure in the cross-section of bars by analysis and treatment these data as shown in fig.2,3 and 4(in it,the effective testing range for the bars is within \6dB area-shaded and the empty area is \12dB).

fig.2
1.The "S"probe method is using the CTS-23 type u.f.d which is made by SHANTOU city in China for matching.The probe is 2.5P20(2.5MHz,PZT,20mm dia.),2.5P14(2.5MHz,PZT,14mm dia.),5P14(5MHz,PZT,14mm dia.) and 5N14(5MHz,14mm dia.-a narrow pulse probe),above these probes were made by SHANTOU city in China.In this testing,due to the 2.5P20,2.5P14 and 5P14(SHANTOU) is possessed of widder initial pulse width so that the observation to difficulty,so eliminated.The results shown in fig.2.

2.The "SR"probe method is using the CST-1 type u.f.d which is made by CHANGZHOU city in China for matching.The probe is 5P12x10x2S3(5MHz,PZT,piezocrystal size is 12x10mm,two piece,its initial incidence angle is 3< when the probe face is plane,below is same),5P12x10x2S6 and 5P12x10x2S9.In this testing,the 5P12x10x2S9 is possessed of narrower effective testing range for the 60mm dia. so eliminated.The results shown in fig.3.

3.The "SD"probe method is using the CTS-26 type u.f.d which is made by SHANTOU city in China for matching.The probe is 5P14,its delay block is made of organic glass by ourself.The straight beam probe is fixed together with the delay block using special tong on the probe.In the outside of delay block it is set up sound-trap to eliminate the interferences of echo within the delay block.


fig.3
The delay block's length ought to take the second interface-echo fall behind the first back-echo exactly to avoid excessive attenuation of sound-energy.In this testing,the delay block's length is 21,26 and 28mm for 40,50 and 60mm dia. separately.The results shown in fig.4.

In fig.2,3 and 4,it shown that "S"probe method is possessed of much small effective testing rangge,but the "SR" and "SD"probemethod is possessed of satisfactory rangge.Apparently,when the inspection is applied around the circumferential face of the bar,the effective testing range will cover the cross-section of bar,therefore it will satisfy the request of testing.In these figures,the solid-line indicated the ideal sound-field defined by the edge of piezocrystal due to diffusion in 0dB for reference and contrast,and the dotted-line indicated the ideal sound-field due to diffusion in 3dB.The effective range defined by testing is uncompletely concerned in dostortion of real sound-field caused by the quality of the probe itself,for example,the making-up technics of the probe,the accuracy of the probe face's curvature,and etc. In addition,the testing error is unavoidable due to the testing is operated by hand.

Conclusion

Generally the twin crystal probe is a


fig.4
integrated construction,it is don't repaired when it is wear out.But the plastic delay block can be replaced easily if it is wear out.Therefore,the "SR" and "SD"probe method all can satisfy the request of testing reliability,but the "SD"probe method is economic and convenience more than the "SR"probe method due to the delay block can be replaced so that the probe-itself is don't wear out.So the "SD"probe method possess more practical purpose.